Most Delicious Coffee Experience: Like having a fancy coffee shop drink, but better for you. The flavors are rich and authentic - especially their caramel and vanilla options which taste like the real deal, not artificial. Zero weird aftertaste that you get with other protein drinks.

‍Actually Keeps You Full: The protein blend really works - I stay satisfied until lunch without the mid-morning cravings I used to get. Plus, the energy is smooth and sustained - no jitters or 2pm crash like with regular coffee.

‍Clean & Effective Formula: Zero sugar, all-natural ingredients, and no artificial junk. Each serving packs 20g of protein which is perfect for a breakfast replacement. I love that I can understand every ingredient on the label.

‍Super Easy Morning Routine: Just mix with hot or cold water/milk and you're done. It dissolves completely (no chalky texture!) and you can make it as strong as you like. I can make it while getting ready in literally 30 seconds.

‍Great Value: Way cheaper than my old Starbucks habit. A month's supply costs less than a week of coffee shop drinks, especially with their subscription option.

Limited Availability: Not being on Amazon is a tad inconvenient at first. You have to order directly from their website, though they do offer free shipping and the process is pretty easy overall.

‍Can't buy at retail stores: The product is great but sometimes I wish I could just pop into a store and grab more.

Authentic Coffee Experience: Like having your regular morning brew, just enhanced with protein. The real coffee extract gives it that genuine taste without trying too hard to be fancy - perfect for coffee purists who don't want their drink messed with too much.

‍Clean & Simple Formula: Zero sugar, no stevia, and a straightforward ingredient list you can actually understand. No weird seed oils or artificial stuff - just clean protein and coffee working together.

‍Customizable Strength: You can make it exactly how you like it. Whether you want it stronger or lighter, the smooth-blending formula lets you control your perfect cup without any clumping or weird textures.

‍Great Value Runner-Up: The second most affordable option out there for protein coffee, making it a solid choice if you're watching your budget but still want quality.

Foam Factor: The foamy texture is a bit off-putting, and honestly, it doesn't taste great. Makes the experience feel less like real coffee and more like a science experiment.

‍Limited Options: Only having one flavor (Original Coffee) is pretty restrictive. Would love to see them branch out with more varieties to keep things interesting.

Authentic Flavor Experience: The caramel actually tastes like real caramel coffee, not that artificial stuff. No stevia aftertaste, which is a huge plus if you're tired of that fake sweetener taste in protein drinks.

‍Variety & Convenience: With 12 different flavors and single-serving packets available, it's super easy to find your favorite and take it on the go. The creamy, milky texture feels like a real coffee shop drink.

‍Effective Appetite Control: Only needed to snack once after drinking it, which is pretty impressive. The clean ingredient list and no artificial additives make it feel like a healthy choice too.

Texture Issues: First sip had clumps and it was overly foamy - definitely not the smooth experience you want from a coffee drink. Plus, it felt too sweet for my taste.

Shipping Struggles: Long delivery times and having to pay for shipping is frustrating when you're running low. Would be nice if they offered faster shipping options.

Protein Packed: A solid 20g of protein per serving makes it a legitimate meal replacement option. The simple natural ingredient list keeps things clean.

Creamy Experience: When it blends well, the milky texture is really satisfying. Perfect for those who want their protein coffee to feel more like a creamy latte.

Coffee Forward: About a cup of coffee per serving means you're getting a real coffee experience, not just coffee-flavored protein. Best for those who don't actually want to taste the coffee though.

Mixing Issues: The clumping and fizzy effect are real problems that make preparation frustrating. It shouldn't be this hard to make a smooth drink.

Sweetness Problems: Really overwhelming sweetness plus an artificial stevia aftertaste makes it hard to enjoy. Would be better with a more balanced flavor profile.

Authentic Caramel Flavor: If you love caramel, this is your drink. The most obvious and authentic caramel taste of all options, without any artificial stevia flavor.

‍Value Proposition: Budget-friendly pricing makes it accessible for daily use. Plus, it blends well and actually keeps you full until lunchtime.

‍Smooth Mixing: No clumps means easy preparation, though you'll need to stir occasionally to deal with settling.

Nutritional Concerns: Only 8g of protein per scoop plus 5g of added sugar isn't ideal for a protein coffee. The ingredient list includes questionable items like seed oils.

‍Settling Issues: While it blends well initially, significant settling means you'll be stirring throughout your drink. Plus, it has the highest carb content of all products tested.

High-Quality Ingredients: Uses 100% arabica coffee and packs an impressive 27g of protein per scoop. The all-natural ingredient list with no fillers or seed oils is a major plus.

‍Clean Formula: Zero sugar and a focus on natural ingredients shows they're serious about quality. The simple ingredient list is refreshingly straightforward.

‍Protein Champion: Highest protein content of all options tested, making it great for those prioritizing protein intake over taste.

Texture Problems: Really struggles with blending, which is a daily frustration. The vanilla flavor doesn't taste authentic.

‍Cost & Convenience: At $2.30 per serving plus shipping, it's on the pricier side. Only having one flavor option feels limiting for the price point.

Balanced Formula: Strikes a decent balance with 18g protein, just 1g sugar, and 100 calories. The taste isn't overly sweet, which is refreshing in this category.

‍Satisfying Results: Keeps you full until lunch and blends well with a frother, making it a reliable meal replacement option.

‍Simple Implementation: No complicated preparation needed - just blend and go.

Coffee Identity Crisis: Tastes more like chocolate milk than coffee, and the flavor is pretty forgettable. The traditional protein shake texture doesn't help its coffee credentials.

‍Practical Concerns: The tub is bulky and takes up too much kitchen space. Plus, the high caffeine content might be too intense for some, causing jitters.